Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Fishinabarrel's avatar

Thanks Dean, I am grateful for this review. I've been wanting to read these books for a while but put them off and I love Laika, so I was very excited to see this. Your review has me still interested but I think I have now appropriately tempered my expectations and know a little more about what to expect.

To add to the conversation a bit, I cannot help but wonder if the dissolution of the family, which you talk about being a recurring theme in an animated film that might not be appropriate for the entire family, might be a bit ironic. I have definitely felt that children's media in particular in the last two decades have really struggled as more and more artists and committee corporations, some of them perhaps with no children of their own, work towards making what they probably feel is the best art they can, and yet succeed at either being an intolerably infantile spectacle that condescends to children's worst impulses, or being maybe a mildly amusing venture into the artists' personal hang-ups or causes they want children to be aware of. I don't know if Wildwood fits into either of these categories, and while It sounds like a labor of love and true talent so that I would certainly not say it is on the level of an empty or braindead (rot) spectacle like a Minions film, it sounds like it might still be still missing something, and maybe that something is what prevents it from being a film the whole family can watch, thus healing some of the dissolution the film seems to observe. A pity the whole family cannot experience it together.

Thanks again for the review!

Betsy's avatar

I have tried several times to read Wildwood but found it both annoying and boring. The movie looks interesting and based on your review I look forward to seeing it. Thank you for the head's up that this is not a movie for children; I couldn't imagine, in my various attempts to get into the book, that a child would find it appealing (a purple haired nose ringed Portland resident, absolutely, and part of what put me off about the book was the relentless way it ran down a list of every Portland stereotype possible).

7 more comments...

Ready for more?