Thanks Dean, I am grateful for this review. I've been wanting to read these books for a while but put them off and I love Laika, so I was very excited to see this. Your review has me still interested but I think I have now appropriately tempered my expectations and know a little more about what to expect.
To add to the conversation a bit, I cannot help but wonder if the dissolution of the family, which you talk about being a recurring theme in an animated film that might not be appropriate for the entire family, might be a bit ironic. I have definitely felt that children's media in particular in the last two decades have really struggled as more and more artists and committee corporations, some of them perhaps with no children of their own, work towards making what they probably feel is the best art they can, and yet succeed at either being an intolerably infantile spectacle that condescends to children's worst impulses, or being maybe a mildly amusing venture into the artists' personal hang-ups or causes they want children to be aware of. I don't know if Wildwood fits into either of these categories, and while It sounds like a labor of love and true talent so that I would certainly not say it is on the level of an empty or braindead (rot) spectacle like a Minions film, it sounds like it might still be still missing something, and maybe that something is what prevents it from being a film the whole family can watch, thus healing some of the dissolution the film seems to observe. A pity the whole family cannot experience it together.
My sense is that the filmmakers probably intended for this to be a “scary kids movie” in the tradition of their earlier work like “Coraline” or classic films like “Labyrinth” or “The Dark Crystal”. I am totally for that type of film, but this goes too far in several places, which is telling in its own right. I definitely agree that the film would be better if those elements were not there. None of them, besides maybe a part about using magic to conceive, are absolutely essential to the plot or themes. At the end of the day, though, I enjoyed it as something only for adults, but it would absolutely be better if it were safe for a wider audience.
I have tried several times to read Wildwood but found it both annoying and boring. The movie looks interesting and based on your review I look forward to seeing it. Thank you for the head's up that this is not a movie for children; I couldn't imagine, in my various attempts to get into the book, that a child would find it appealing (a purple haired nose ringed Portland resident, absolutely, and part of what put me off about the book was the relentless way it ran down a list of every Portland stereotype possible).
I think you’re conflating several terms and conceptual and historical processes. I don’t see the tension between technology and nature you describe in the movie; I don't see modernization, secularization, or a lack of spirituality alongside the rise of AI and Silicon Valley. You’re using the movie to impose a Catholic, conservative view of morality, family, and correctness. The story is about grief, complex family relationships, vulnerability and maturity, authority, and political struggle—not about how the dissolution of conservative, old, and violent visions of family should lead to a return to the family in the face of the dangers posed by Indigenous, scientific, or other worldviews.
Thank you for reading and commenting! There are definitely many ways to read the film. I agree with all of the themes you mentioned being present. As for imposing a Catholic or conservative view, I do want to add some context. For one, this Substack is intended to be for Catholics in the sense that it assumes the religion is true and at least my interpretations/reviews are geared toward relating to how a Catholic specifically would view the film. I would agree that a non-Catholic might view it differently. I do not intend for my perspective to be specifically conservative, though, and I do not believe a stereotypical conservative who would be opposed to any critique of colonization would appreciate this film.
My perspective is that all experience is interpretation and that we can never leave our own presuppositions, history of experiences, and biological responsivity totally behind us. At the same time, I do not think an analysis of a film is entirely subjective, meaning that no analysis is wrong or incorrect. The meaning of a text is generated in the meeting between the text and the observer, and is not entirely located in either one. Of course, not everyone agrees (including Catholics) with that take on interpretation. I do think the themes I mention are explicitly present in the film, but the way I synthesize them is definitely up for debate. The breakup of the family are the two inciting events of the whole film. They seem to be intended to parallel each other. Yes, it is about grief, but grief of what? The loss of family. They do both symbolize an inability to let go of one’s grief (Prue’s parents cannot let go of the fact they cannot conceive and Alexandria cannot let go of her son - both lead them to using forces they cannot understand and hurt them in the end). The movie does not explicitly name AI or Silicon Valley, but it is implied that “dark magic” is industrialized technology (robots, gears, and so on). The PR around the film has also positioned the film as the ultimate anti-AI work with stop-motion requiring immense patience and human work vs. the quick and easy AI “art” route.
The summation you gave of my argument is also not exactly what I intended to communicate (which is probably on me!). I do not believe rationalistic/materialist scientific or Indigenous/ecological perspectives are without merit (although I do not believe in either as isolated ideologies). The film is sympathetic to both of these perspectives, even if it can track how they can fail or hurt others. I would agree with that. That is true of Catholicism, too. The point, which I believe is a part of this film, is that the world is out of balance. The Ivy is the symbol of that here. It is neither good or bad. Alexandra uses it to create and control technology to bring back her son, which leads to her exile. However, it ultimately consumes and kills her (hence technology being considered a “bad” magic, although I think we are meant to not take that and Alexandria’s exile as accurate moral judgments). On the other side, the tree has legitimate power, but it fails when the elders attempt to speak to it. For Prue, though, she is able to speak to it and ultimately can wield the Ivy to save her brother partly I think because she can see the deeper conflicts at play. She is the only one who is able to unite the bandits and the North Wood mystics, for example.
The "anti-AI" messaging is not just in Wildwood's PR; it's in the movie itself! If you stay for the credits (and I encourage everyone to), it shows how they sewed the characters' clothing by hand, put the figurines together, and moved them little by little.
I saw this movie mainly because of this review. Ultimately, I liked the movie. It did toe a line between kid (fairly simple plot) and adult themes and violence (mild, but still no good for kids younger than teenagers). The animation is well done and there was some good emotional exposition, a well developed villain story, and plenty of breathtaking moments. A solid B in my opinion. Not an instant classic. But not totally forgettable.
Glad to see this on my feed after watching it last night. I was mesmerized by how alive the animation felt, the mythos of the Oregon woods come to life, and overall just wrapped up in the vibes- it felt so fresh.
Dissolution of the family unit, yet family is shown to be valued above all. The parents couldn’t have their happy ending without havings kids to pour their life into, a veiled peace of modernity. The central antagonist had her happy life briefly and then spent the rest of her life using technology to try and recapture her happiness and morph the world into a place where the cause of her pain would never occur again.
This is an interesting review. I was curious about what the movie would be like having read the books. I agree that the books definitely highlight the dissolution of the family, though I don’t think it was the intent of the authors. It actually was a negative take away for me, because it seemed so..normal in the book, and there was no deference given to the parents. It was as if the parents were the village idiots. There was also a great deal of nature worshipping in the book but it never seemed to be vilified, but only engaged with as an ultimate good. These things made it a hard no for children in my mind. Though the book was really well written with excellent story development. I am slightly curious to watch the movie now to see how it aligns with the book.
Thanks Dean, I am grateful for this review. I've been wanting to read these books for a while but put them off and I love Laika, so I was very excited to see this. Your review has me still interested but I think I have now appropriately tempered my expectations and know a little more about what to expect.
To add to the conversation a bit, I cannot help but wonder if the dissolution of the family, which you talk about being a recurring theme in an animated film that might not be appropriate for the entire family, might be a bit ironic. I have definitely felt that children's media in particular in the last two decades have really struggled as more and more artists and committee corporations, some of them perhaps with no children of their own, work towards making what they probably feel is the best art they can, and yet succeed at either being an intolerably infantile spectacle that condescends to children's worst impulses, or being maybe a mildly amusing venture into the artists' personal hang-ups or causes they want children to be aware of. I don't know if Wildwood fits into either of these categories, and while It sounds like a labor of love and true talent so that I would certainly not say it is on the level of an empty or braindead (rot) spectacle like a Minions film, it sounds like it might still be still missing something, and maybe that something is what prevents it from being a film the whole family can watch, thus healing some of the dissolution the film seems to observe. A pity the whole family cannot experience it together.
Thanks again for the review!
My sense is that the filmmakers probably intended for this to be a “scary kids movie” in the tradition of their earlier work like “Coraline” or classic films like “Labyrinth” or “The Dark Crystal”. I am totally for that type of film, but this goes too far in several places, which is telling in its own right. I definitely agree that the film would be better if those elements were not there. None of them, besides maybe a part about using magic to conceive, are absolutely essential to the plot or themes. At the end of the day, though, I enjoyed it as something only for adults, but it would absolutely be better if it were safe for a wider audience.
I have tried several times to read Wildwood but found it both annoying and boring. The movie looks interesting and based on your review I look forward to seeing it. Thank you for the head's up that this is not a movie for children; I couldn't imagine, in my various attempts to get into the book, that a child would find it appealing (a purple haired nose ringed Portland resident, absolutely, and part of what put me off about the book was the relentless way it ran down a list of every Portland stereotype possible).
I think you’re conflating several terms and conceptual and historical processes. I don’t see the tension between technology and nature you describe in the movie; I don't see modernization, secularization, or a lack of spirituality alongside the rise of AI and Silicon Valley. You’re using the movie to impose a Catholic, conservative view of morality, family, and correctness. The story is about grief, complex family relationships, vulnerability and maturity, authority, and political struggle—not about how the dissolution of conservative, old, and violent visions of family should lead to a return to the family in the face of the dangers posed by Indigenous, scientific, or other worldviews.
Thank you for reading and commenting! There are definitely many ways to read the film. I agree with all of the themes you mentioned being present. As for imposing a Catholic or conservative view, I do want to add some context. For one, this Substack is intended to be for Catholics in the sense that it assumes the religion is true and at least my interpretations/reviews are geared toward relating to how a Catholic specifically would view the film. I would agree that a non-Catholic might view it differently. I do not intend for my perspective to be specifically conservative, though, and I do not believe a stereotypical conservative who would be opposed to any critique of colonization would appreciate this film.
My perspective is that all experience is interpretation and that we can never leave our own presuppositions, history of experiences, and biological responsivity totally behind us. At the same time, I do not think an analysis of a film is entirely subjective, meaning that no analysis is wrong or incorrect. The meaning of a text is generated in the meeting between the text and the observer, and is not entirely located in either one. Of course, not everyone agrees (including Catholics) with that take on interpretation. I do think the themes I mention are explicitly present in the film, but the way I synthesize them is definitely up for debate. The breakup of the family are the two inciting events of the whole film. They seem to be intended to parallel each other. Yes, it is about grief, but grief of what? The loss of family. They do both symbolize an inability to let go of one’s grief (Prue’s parents cannot let go of the fact they cannot conceive and Alexandria cannot let go of her son - both lead them to using forces they cannot understand and hurt them in the end). The movie does not explicitly name AI or Silicon Valley, but it is implied that “dark magic” is industrialized technology (robots, gears, and so on). The PR around the film has also positioned the film as the ultimate anti-AI work with stop-motion requiring immense patience and human work vs. the quick and easy AI “art” route.
The summation you gave of my argument is also not exactly what I intended to communicate (which is probably on me!). I do not believe rationalistic/materialist scientific or Indigenous/ecological perspectives are without merit (although I do not believe in either as isolated ideologies). The film is sympathetic to both of these perspectives, even if it can track how they can fail or hurt others. I would agree with that. That is true of Catholicism, too. The point, which I believe is a part of this film, is that the world is out of balance. The Ivy is the symbol of that here. It is neither good or bad. Alexandra uses it to create and control technology to bring back her son, which leads to her exile. However, it ultimately consumes and kills her (hence technology being considered a “bad” magic, although I think we are meant to not take that and Alexandria’s exile as accurate moral judgments). On the other side, the tree has legitimate power, but it fails when the elders attempt to speak to it. For Prue, though, she is able to speak to it and ultimately can wield the Ivy to save her brother partly I think because she can see the deeper conflicts at play. She is the only one who is able to unite the bandits and the North Wood mystics, for example.
The "anti-AI" messaging is not just in Wildwood's PR; it's in the movie itself! If you stay for the credits (and I encourage everyone to), it shows how they sewed the characters' clothing by hand, put the figurines together, and moved them little by little.
I saw this movie mainly because of this review. Ultimately, I liked the movie. It did toe a line between kid (fairly simple plot) and adult themes and violence (mild, but still no good for kids younger than teenagers). The animation is well done and there was some good emotional exposition, a well developed villain story, and plenty of breathtaking moments. A solid B in my opinion. Not an instant classic. But not totally forgettable.
Glad to see this on my feed after watching it last night. I was mesmerized by how alive the animation felt, the mythos of the Oregon woods come to life, and overall just wrapped up in the vibes- it felt so fresh.
Dissolution of the family unit, yet family is shown to be valued above all. The parents couldn’t have their happy ending without havings kids to pour their life into, a veiled peace of modernity. The central antagonist had her happy life briefly and then spent the rest of her life using technology to try and recapture her happiness and morph the world into a place where the cause of her pain would never occur again.
This is an interesting review. I was curious about what the movie would be like having read the books. I agree that the books definitely highlight the dissolution of the family, though I don’t think it was the intent of the authors. It actually was a negative take away for me, because it seemed so..normal in the book, and there was no deference given to the parents. It was as if the parents were the village idiots. There was also a great deal of nature worshipping in the book but it never seemed to be vilified, but only engaged with as an ultimate good. These things made it a hard no for children in my mind. Though the book was really well written with excellent story development. I am slightly curious to watch the movie now to see how it aligns with the book.